America’s Sweetheart, Courtney Love’s first and so far only solo album, is absolute shit. It’s fucking confused and drug addled, and unfortunately not in a good way. I mean what the fuck happened to the woman who screamed on Pretty on the Inside? There’s almost no evidence of the intelligence and lyrical power that makes that album sound fresh even today. Plus the production is absolutely horrible.
The thing I don’t like about Courtney’s lyrics nowadays is that she seems to have forgotten to paint interesting images and create powerful metaphors. Now she sometimes resigns herself to pop culture references, and they go as lame as referencing the “why’d the chicken cross the road” joke several times in one song. Why? Why is there a song about how much she loves men? And a song that sounds like she wrote it as an early-20-something bitching about her boyfriend’s obsession with playing “Stairway to Heaven”? These things sound like songs she put on the back-burner (or just plain threw out) when she was younger, and apparently more able to apply a filter.
“Sunset Strip” could be a Guns N Roses song. There are some interesting lyrics, but overall it’s overproduced shit. And that applies to almost all of the songs on here. It sounds like Pink with a fucked up voice and slightly more credibility. Although I think Courtney’s voice sounds better than on Celebrity Skin, at least in some cases. But the God, the overproduced guitars and overproduced lyrics. Why?
There are only two good songs on the album, the cheesy but insightful “Uncool”, and the hideously brutal “Plague” (aka “Life Despite God”). “Plague” is a fucking mess. It opens with a sloppy organ and grows in intensity with screaming that rivals the end of “Burn Black” until it collapses at the end with Courtney wheezing “all my love’s in vain, cannot find a vein”. It seems to have Courtney waffling between mocking people who blame her for Kurt’s suicide and believing it herself. It’s a shocking song, really. Considering the childishness and shallowness that surrounds it, the emotional intensity is even more ravaging. Even though the guitars are less bludgeoning, some of it rivals Hole’s first album. It’s really an awesome song.
The biggest problem with this album is basically that no one knew what they wanted it to be. The producer didn’t know how to create anything but radio-friendly pop rock (the guy worked with Matchbox 20 for God’s sake), so that’s what he wanted it to be. Linda Perry apparently wanted it to be a Pink album, and the record label obviously wanted it to be a radio smash, or something. And Courtney was so fucked up on crack at the time that she didn’t know what the hell she wanted. What it should’ve been is a horrifyingly honest album in the vein of “Plague”. What’s wrong with this album, and everything Courtney’s done post-Kurt, is that it’s not honest. Maybe if she spent less time avoiding her true feelings, like in songs like “Zeppelin Song” and “Hello” and song after song after song, this could’ve been truly powerful. But whatever.





